Resisting the Transplant: Why the EU Must Preserve IPRED’s Rule- Based Proportionality in IP Enforcement

In this paper, Francesca Ferrari analyses the EU system of IP enforcement under IPRED, focusing on the role of proportionality in remedies and injunctive relief, and arguing against importing the US post-eBay model into EU law. Watch the webinar organised by 4iP Council, and a discussion with the author on this subject.

Download

INTRODUCTION AND RESEARCH OBJECTIVES

This study examines whether Directive 2004/48/EC (IPRED) has effectively established a minimum harmonisation framework for the civil enforcement of intellectual property rights (IPRs) within the European Union. It further explores the rationale and limits of the national divergences that persist in practice, assesses the function and boundaries of the proportionality principle within the enforcement architecture, and contrasts the European model with the United States’ post-eBay framework for injunctive relief. Through this comparative analysis, the study aims to evaluate whether a legislative revision of IPRED is normatively and practically desirable.

Download to continue reading